Discipline in Pre-Schoolers: This apparently simple question is the cause of some fairly heated, if good-natured, debate. Let’s examine the issues for both the parents and the providers of early learning centre education.
Early learning centre age children – Are preschoolers ever really “bad”?
The answer to this depends on the ages one is speaking of – and it is worth remembering that an individual child’s behaviours may not necessarily conform to any child psychologist’s graph!
However, generally, up to around 3-4 years of age, most children won’t deliberately misbehave. They may do things they know their parent or care provider didn’t want – for a game for example or as teasing or humour and certainly toddlers can throw temper tantrums (which are not misbehaviours). These things though, aren’t usually expressions of bad behaviour in the sense of deliberate non-compliance with an intent to assert their authority over that of the adult concerned.
That factor (intention) is used to differentiate real misbehaviour from play, humour or sometimes simply not understanding.
Later pre-school ages and Discipline
Around the age of 4-5, most children will start showing tendencies towards genuine misbehaviour. As far as is known, this discipline developmental stage is virtually universal.
It isn’t entirely clear why this develops but it is assumed to be an undesirable, if necessary, offshoot of children trying to establish their place in the world and to explore its various boundaries. Essentially, that means they’re no longer automatically subservient to what adults around them say should or should not happen. They will start to ask themselves “Why is that bad?” and decide to do the opposite to see:
- firstly, what happens;
- secondly, just what the consequences will be.
There is a furious debate in child psychology about what age children start to really understand what ‘good’ and ‘bad’ means in behavioural terms. Some research suggests that toddlers and even babies can distinguish between desirable and undesirable behaviours but that conclusion is disputed.
What is not argued about is that, by 3-5 years of age or so, most children have some understanding of what constitutes good or bad behaviour. They may not always fully understand the ‘why’ but even where they do, they are increasingly willing and able to choose to behave in a fashion they know is ‘bad’.
When they consciously make that choice, they are simply being ‘bad’ – though such behaviours are, typically, still a case of the child experimenting with the world rather than having malicious intent or seeking calculated advantage through their actions.
Certain cognitive conditions may cause younger children to constantly and maliciously misbehave but they’re rare and aren’t discussed further here.
Reaction
Most child psychologists and early learning centre specialists agree that punishment is not an option when trying to help children understand why a behaviour of theirs was ‘bad’. As many experts say, “You can’t teach a child what’s good or bad behaviour through punishment any more than you can use punishment to teach them to read”.
However, it might be equally unwise to ignore intentional bad behaviour. Children must learn that their choices around behaviour will often have consequences and that bad behaviour just can’t be overlooked.
Our approach is typically to quietly take a misbehaving child to a calm but separate area and to ask them to think about what they have just done. We encourage them to empathise with others who might have been affected adversely by their actions. We also explain why such behaviours are wrong and undesirable.
In the vast majority of cases, this quiet and calm exploration is all that’s required to help set children on the right road towards controlling the negative inclinations we all sometimes experience.
If you’d like to know more about our approaches to discipline, why not arrange an appointment to come along and meet us?









